Land policy and Land reform in Sub-Saharan Africa: Consensus, Confusion and Controversy
Brink, Rogier van den
This draft paper has been presented at the occasion of the Symposium 'Land redistribution in Southern Africa', 6-7 November 2002, Pretoria SA. A final version of this paper will be published in February 2003.
How often have you heard someone say that land, and land reform, is a very important development issue, but it is politically sensitivee? And how often has that description then provided an excuse for inaction? In this paper, in an effort not to continue this tradition, I attempt to give a brief overview of the most important, and politically sensitive, issues surrounding land reform. And I indicate where, I think, consensus, confusion or controversy exists among the stakeholderss?Government officials, policy makers and analysts, leadership of the farming communities, and development partners. The paper is in two parts. The first part focuses on property rights in landdit gives a short narrative of some of the key land tenuree or land policyy issues and the emerging consensus around them. I suggest that, while these issues do remain politically sensitive, there is a solid consensus emerging on how to deal with them, but only once we have cleared up the considerable confusion surrounding private and common property, and formal and informal rights. The second part addresses the redistribution of property rights in landdredistributive land reform. Here, political sensitivityy is often a euphemism for explosivee. The good news is that I think we are well on our way in reaching consensus around the problem and the need to address it with a heightened sense of urgency. But the bad news is that we do not seem to agree on the solution: the how to do itt part. Without trying to artificially create consensus, I suggest a policy framework within which the various contending solutions can compete and prove their effectiveness on the grounddthere where it matters.
Event: Symposium Land Redistribution in Southern Africa
Only personal, non-commercial use of this document is allowed.